Giants fans, it's almost a given that you feel a certain way about the team's quarterback situation. You know, it's been a topic that gets a lot of discussion. There's a real sense of wanting things to change, and that's completely fair, you know? This feeling has been building for a while, and people are ready for some clear answers.

So, when a well-known voice like Todd McShay speaks up about the New York Giants, people really pay attention. He's an NFL draft analyst who has a way of looking at things that can be quite different. His latest thoughts on what the Giants might do in the upcoming draft are, in a way, very bold. They might even make some Giants fans raise an eyebrow or two, or perhaps even sigh a little.

His ideas seem to challenge some common thoughts about what the team needs most. It's not just about picking a player; it's about a whole strategy. This message from McShay gives us a lot to think about, especially as the draft approaches. We're going to look closely at what he's saying and what it could mean for the Giants' future, you know, for real.

• Florerias En Los Mochis
• John Thompson Legacy Center

Table of Contents

• Todd McShay: A Closer Look at the Analyst
• The Frustration is Real: Why Giants Fans Feel the Way They Do
• McShay's Surprising Draft Vision: The Quarterback Question
• Shedeur Sanders: The Meeting That Made Waves
• Abdul Carter: A Defensive Gem for Big Blue?
• The Jalen Milroe Twist: A Later Round Quarterback Move
• The Daboll Factor: Coaching Input on Draft Picks
• What This Means for the Giants' Future Outlook
• Looking Ahead: The Draft Landscape for New York
• Frequently Asked Questions

Todd McShay: A Closer Look at the Analyst

Todd McShay is, in some respects, a very familiar face and voice to anyone who follows college football and the NFL draft. He's been around for a long time, sharing his thoughts on young players coming into the league. He's known for bringing you inside his special world as an NFL talent evaluator, which is pretty cool, you know?

He has a way of looking at players that's quite detailed. From the regular football season to the actual draft, he's always keeping an eye on the top players. He used to be a big part of ESPN's NFL draft coverage alongside Mel Kiper Jr., which was a huge deal. Lately, he's been a bit less visible on TV, but he's still very active with his own show.

His show, "The McShay Show," can be found on Spotify and YouTube, which is a good spot for premium insights every single week. He really does bring a lot of experience to the table, and his big board rankings are often talked about. He's been through a lot, too, like when he was removed from a broadcast a few years ago, which was quite a moment. He keeps going, though, offering his unique take on the future stars of the NFL, which is really something.

• Honey Cream Models
• The Two Guys Bow Ties

Personal Details & Bio Data

The Frustration is Real: Why Giants Fans Feel the Way They Do

Giants fans, it's very clear, are feeling quite frustrated with the quarterback situation. And, you know, they have every right to feel that way. For a while now, there's been a lot of talk and not a lot of settled answers at that very important position. People want to see a clear path forward, and that's completely understandable.

There's a sense of longing for stability and a player who can really lead the team to consistent wins. This feeling of wanting more, or something different, is something many fans share. It's not just about one game or one season; it's about the bigger picture for the team. This kind of feeling can really shape how fans view any new information about the draft, or player moves, for that matter.

So, when an analyst like Todd McShay offers up a view that might seem to go against what many fans expect or hope for, it really gets people talking. It touches on that very real frustration that's been bubbling up. Fans are looking for reasons to be excited, and a bold plan, you know, can be both thrilling and a little worrying at the same time.

McShay's Surprising Draft Vision: The Quarterback Question

Todd McShay has put out some mock draft ideas that are, in a way, pretty surprising for Giants fans. His latest version, you know, might not be what many people expect or even like. He's suggesting some picks that go against the grain, especially when it comes to the quarterback spot. This is where his "bold message" really comes into play, actually.

One of the more eye-opening scenarios McShay has talked about involves Shedeur Sanders. He's suggested that if Sanders doesn't get picked by the Browns early on – and McShay isn't completely sure about that pick – then he sees the Giants possibly taking Sanders at the No. 3 spot. That's a very high pick for a quarterback, and it's a big decision, you know?

This idea, in a way, directly addresses the Giants' quarterback situation, but perhaps not in the way some fans might have pictured. It's a move that would certainly get people talking and, in some respects, redefine the team's immediate future. This kind of projection from a respected analyst like McShay really makes you think about all the possibilities that could happen on draft day, doesn't it?

It's worth noting that McShay has also floated other ideas, showing how fluid the draft process can be. He's not just sticking to one path. This willingness to explore different scenarios is part of what makes his analysis interesting, even if it sometimes feels a little bit out there for some fans.

Shedeur Sanders: The Meeting That Made Waves

Now, talking about Shedeur Sanders and the Giants brings up a very interesting point. NFL insider Todd McShay shared some information that, you know, really made some waves. He detailed that Shedeur Sanders's meeting with Giants head coach Brian Daboll was, to put it mildly, a disaster. That's a pretty strong word to use, isn't it?

This piece of information adds a whole new layer to the idea of the Giants picking Sanders, especially at such a high spot like No. 3. If a meeting between a potential top draft pick and the head coach goes that poorly, it typically raises a lot of questions. It makes you wonder, you know, how serious the team could be about that player if there's such a disconnect right from the start.

Despite this reported "disaster" of a meeting, McShay still mentioned the possibility of the Giants going for Sanders. This just goes to show how much uncertainty there is around draft projections. It's almost like McShay is saying, "Look, anything can happen, even if it seems unlikely on the surface." It's a very complex situation, and this meeting detail certainly doesn't make it any simpler for fans to guess what might happen.

It also highlights the importance of those private meetings between players and teams. They can really shape a team's opinion, and sometimes, they can even change the whole direction of a draft board. This particular detail from McShay makes his projection of Sanders to the Giants even bolder, considering the reported friction.

Abdul Carter: A Defensive Gem for Big Blue?

While the quarterback talk is definitely a big part of McShay's message, he's also looked at other positions for the Giants. In one of his mock drafts, McShay actually projected Abdul Carter to the Giants at the No. 3 pick. This is quite different from the quarterback discussion, and it shows a different kind of plan for the team, you know?

McShay called Carter a "top defensive talent," which is a really strong endorsement. This suggests that the Giants might, in some respects, decide to fill a major hole on the defensive side of the ball with their very first pick. For a team that needs to improve in many areas, getting a top-tier defensive player could be a very smart move, actually.

This idea of taking a defensive player early on, instead of a quarterback, is something that has been talked about by other analysts too. A good article from Breer, where he talked with McShay and Jeremiah, seemed to strengthen the belief that the Giants might not take a quarterback early and instead focus on filling a ton of other holes on the team. This just goes to show, you know, there are many ways to build a good team.

So, while the quarterback situation gets a lot of the spotlight, McShay is also pointing to the possibility of a different approach. Getting a player like Carter could really help the Giants' defense immediately. It's a strategic choice that prioritizes overall team strength over just one position, which is a pretty sound way to think about it.

The Jalen Milroe Twist: A Later Round Quarterback Move

Adding another interesting layer to McShay's thoughts on the Giants' draft strategy is his projection of a bold quarterback move for Jalen Milroe later in the draft. This is a very different idea from taking a quarterback at No. 3. It suggests a patient approach, you know, waiting to see how the board falls and then making a move for a signal-caller in a later round.

This kind of plan could appeal to a team that wants to address other needs first but still sees the value in bringing in a new arm for the future. It's like saying, "We'll get our defensive talent, or offensive line help, and then we'll look for a quarterback with potential." This strategy is, in some respects, less risky than a top-five pick on a quarterback, but it still shows a commitment to finding a new player at that position.

Projecting Milroe later means McShay sees some good traits there, but perhaps not enough to warrant an early pick. It's a way to get a player who could develop, without putting all your eggs in one basket right at the start of the draft. This kind of two-pronged approach – top defensive talent early, quarterback later – is a very real possibility for teams looking to rebuild or strengthen their roster across the board.

It also shows that McShay is considering different scenarios for the Giants. He's not just saying "QB or bust" at the top. He's exploring how they might get a quarterback without necessarily using their very first pick on one, which is a smart way to look at the whole draft board, you know, for sure.

The Daboll Factor: Coaching Input on Draft Picks

A very important part of any draft discussion for the Giants is the input from head coach Brian Daboll. McShay brought up a point that's really worth considering: it would basically be extremely dysfunctional for the Giants to draft a quarterback over Daboll's objections. This highlights the critical role a head coach plays in player selections, you know?

If the coach isn't on board with a particular player, especially a quarterback, it can cause all sorts of problems down the line. A quarterback needs to be in sync with the coaching staff, and if there's disagreement right from the start, that's not a good sign. This kind of internal conflict could really hurt the team's progress and chemistry, which is something no one wants to see.

This point from McShay strengthens the idea that the Giants' draft strategy will likely involve a lot of collaboration between the front office and the coaching staff. It's not just about who's available; it's also about who fits the coach's vision and system. The reported "disaster" meeting with Shedeur Sanders, for example, ties directly into this. If Daboll isn't keen on a player, it makes that pick far less likely, no matter how talented the player might be, actually.

So, any bold moves McShay suggests, especially at quarterback, have to be seen through the lens of Daboll's preferences. It's a very real factor that shapes what the Giants might do. The team needs to be united in its decisions, and the coach's buy-in is a huge piece of that puzzle, you know, for sure.

What This Means for the Giants' Future Outlook

Suddenly, forecasting what the Giants might do in the first two rounds of the draft has become much harder, hasn't it? Todd McShay's bold plan for Big Blue, with its different scenarios for quarterback and defensive talent, adds a lot of complexity. It suggests that the team could go in a few very different directions, which is both exciting and a little nerve-wracking for fans.

If the Giants follow a path similar to what McShay has laid out – perhaps taking a top defensive player like Abdul Carter early, and then looking for a quarterback like Jalen Milroe later – it shows a commitment to building a well-rounded roster. This approach focuses on filling multiple needs rather than just one big one. It's a way to get more talent on the team right away, which is pretty important.

The idea of Shedeur Sanders at No. 3, despite the reported meeting issues, still lingers as a possibility in McShay's mind. This means that the Giants are keeping all their options open, or at least, McShay believes they are. It’s a very dynamic situation, and the team's decisions will have a big impact on their performance in the coming seasons. This kind of flexibility in their draft strategy is, in a way, a good thing, as it allows them to adapt to how the draft board unfolds.

Ultimately, McShay's insights give Giants fans a lot to chew on. They present a future that might not be what everyone expects, but one that could still lead to a stronger team overall. It’s about understanding that there are many paths to building a winning roster, and the Giants seem to be exploring a few of them, you know?

Looking Ahead: The Draft Landscape for New York

As we look ahead to the upcoming NFL Draft, the landscape for the New York Giants, as seen through Todd McShay's eyes, appears quite interesting. His projections, whether it's Shedeur Sanders at No. 3 or Abdul Carter followed by Jalen Milroe, show that the team has some big choices to make. These choices will, in some respects, shape the team for years to come.

The fact that Giants fans are frustrated with the quarterback situation is a key factor here. The team knows they need to address this, but how they do it is the big question. McShay's message suggests they might not take the most obvious route, which could be a bit of a surprise. It's a very fluid situation, and things can change quickly in the world of draft analysis, actually.

Fans can keep up with McShay's latest thoughts by checking out "The McShay Show" on platforms like Spotify. He often updates his big board and offers premium insights, which can give a better sense of his current thinking. This ongoing analysis helps fans stay informed about all the different ways the draft could play out for their team.

It's important for Giants fans to remember that mock drafts are just that: mocks. They are educated guesses, but they are not set in stone. However, McShay's bold statements do give us a very good idea of the kinds of discussions happening behind the scenes and the different strategies the Giants might be considering. It’s a pretty exciting time for football fans, you know, as the draft draws closer.

Learn more about Giants draft strategy on our site. You can also link to this page for more detailed player profiles.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did Todd McShay say about the Giants' quarterback situation?

Todd McShay has, in a way, offered a few different ideas. He suggested that Shedeur Sanders could go to the Giants at No. 3 if the Browns don't pick him. He also talked about a bold move for Jalen Milroe later in the draft. These ideas show he thinks the Giants might get a quarterback, but perhaps not in the way some expect, you know?

Did Todd McShay mock Abdul Carter to the Giants?

Yes, he did. Todd McShay mocked Abdul Carter to the Giants at the No. 3 spot. He called Carter a top defensive talent. This suggests a focus on filling defensive holes early in the draft, which is a very different path from taking a quarterback with the first pick, actually.

What was the issue with Shedeur Sanders' meeting with Brian Daboll?

NFL insider Todd McShay reported that Shedeur Sanders's meeting with Giants head coach Brian Daboll was, in a way, a disaster. This suggests a significant problem or disconnect during their interaction. It's a very important detail that could affect the Giants' interest in Sanders, you know, for real.

For more insights from a respected source, you can check out ESPN's NFL Draft coverage.